From the basement of the American League Central, the outlook is bleak for the Indians. How bleak? Consider this: Cliff Lee (2.96 ERA and all) picked up just his third win of the year yesterday in an outing that marked his tenth consecutive quality start. Fausto Carmona, our supposed number two starter, has an ERA of 7.42. He's largely to blame for a team that leads the majors in walks (231) and is second to last in ERA--behind only the Nationals--at 5.38. Things have gotten to the point where, if the list of maimed Indians decided to disassociate themselves from the club and form an expansion team they would probably be better than the team the Tribe currently fields. The list, which already included Hafner, Westbrook, Reyes, Lewis, Laffey, Smith, and Betancourt, expanded this past week with the addition of Sizemore and Cabrera. And yet, at 10 games below .500, the Indians are only seven games behind the first place Tigers.
Mark Shapiro has thus far refrained from becoming a seller (in a market overflowing with buyers)--presumably because he believes the team still has a chance to rebound: "People may think we're crazy, but we still like the core of our team." But this proclamation hasn't stopped the rumor mill from churning; I've already heard the names of Mark DeRosa, Jamey Carroll, Cliff Lee, Carl Pavano, Jhonny Peralta, and Victor Martinez brought up in a variety of unfledged trade scenarios. While I don't propose trading away Lee or V-Mart, I do believe the Indians should try to piece together a couple trades. Transactions don't have to, and shouldn't indicate a resignation. The Indians are in desperate need of a reallocation of talent--both at the lower levels of their system and on their big league club.
There is a logjam of talented corner infielders that needs to be addressed. Jhonny Peralta, barring any unforeseeable trade or circumstance, looks to be the Indians' third baseman going forward. Uncertainty surrounding his ability to make the sudden transition prompted the Tribe to acquire DeRosa in the offseason, but injuries (and a simple attempt to create a spark by mixing things up) have influenced Wedge to play Peralta at the hot corner with increasing regularity. Meanwhile, the other corner has been occupied by Victor Martinez, Ryan Garko, and DeRosa. Seeing as how Martinez will inevitably tuck away his catcher's mitt for good in the near future, and seeing (furthermore) how his bat is irreplaceable in the lineup, something's gotta give with other corner infield alternatives. There simply isn't room for all of them. DeRosa doesn't factor into the equation at all, as he will be gone by the end of the year--probably sooner. But Garko does, and he's not alone.
Many fans have conditioned themselves to overlook his name by this point, but the once-promising (and perhaps once-again promising) prospect that the Tribe received in the Coco Crisp deal is, in fact, still around. Andy Marte had plenty of opportunities to prove he deserved a spot on the 25-man roster, but he struggled and didn't seem capable of making the necessary adjustments in the Show. However, since clearing waivers at the year's outset, he's 43-131 (.328) with five home runs and 26 RBIs for the Clippers. Despite the fact that the "Marte Experiment" seemed to drag on for a quarter of a century in itself, the kid is still only 25 years old. On the same team is Jordan Brown (.327 / 7 / 26), Michael Aubrey (.322 / 5 / 24), and the highly regarded, though currently underperforming Wes Hodges (.275 / 1 / 15). As you head further down the ladder, you bump into Beau Mills, Matt McBride, and first-rounder Lonnie Chisenhall. Not to mention that some view Matt LaPorta as a future corner infielder.
Without rattling off another list, suffice it to say that the team is similarly cluttered in outfield alternatives. In some ways I feel that Sizemore's DL stint is a golden opportunity to get an extended look at Crowe and perhaps LaPorta. But then again, if they go on a tear, what do you do when Sizemore gets back? Wedge has already resorted to rotating one of the corner outfield spots to create playing opportunities for Garko and DeRosa--usually at Francisco's expense.
Yet for all that, there is actually a shortage of middle infield talent and quality pitching depth. Don't get me wrong, the Indians have quite a few hurlers--so many, in fact, that taking on pitching without first unloading pitching hardly sounds like a winning solution. The issue is that Scott Lewis (L), Zach Jackson (L), Jeremy Sowers (L), David Huff (L), and ultimately Chuck Lofgren (L) are all cut from the same left-handed, soft-tossing, spot-targeting, end-of-the-rotation mold. I'll leave Aaron Laffey off that list, though some would argue he belongs there, as well. Their styles--from the way they pace the game to their pitching arsenal and its effectiveness--are so similar that it's hardly a wonder none of them have been able to find consistent success at the big league level. In a given series, opponents probably aren't challenged enough to alter their approach from one pitcher to the next.
Who knows how this season will play out? I don't think this team has what it takes to win consistently, but stranger things have happened. As Fausto's nightmarish season unfolds, especially in light of the question marks surrounding the durability and overall potential of Westbrook and Reyes moving forward, the Indians have little option but to turn their sights towards acquiring a starter or two that can slide comfortably into the rotation. Easier said than done, I know. It seems pretty obvious to me that trading Lee would be devastating to any chance the team has of contending next year.